The Phantom Tenant: Why Your Due Diligence Process is Your Investment's Most Critical Defense

For those of us who own and manage residential rental properties, the search for a new tenant is a high-stakes moment. We’re not just filling a unit; we’re selecting a partner for the next year or more, someone who holds the keys to our cash flow and the condition of our asset. A great tenant means peace of mind and predictable returns. A bad one? Well, we all know the nightmare that follows.

What many landlords may not fully appreciate is the severity and sophistication of a growing threat: fraudulent due diligence documents being submitted with rental applications. This isn’t the occasional, clumsy forgery from a desperate renter. This is an industrialized problem, where "phantom tenants"—applicants whose financial lives are entirely fabricated—are actively gaming the system.

If you own a multi-family building, this is a risk you simply cannot afford to ignore.

The Problem is Widespread: Looking at the Canadian Data

The statistics coming out of Canada's major rental markets are, frankly, alarming. In high-demand areas, you should be operating on the assumption that a significant percentage of applications are compromised.

While solid national figures are hard to consolidate, the data points emerging from major city centers are a massive red flag. Property management firms in markets like Toronto have reported that over 50% of screened rental applications contain some form of fraudulent discrepancy. Think about that for a moment: one in every two applications you review could be hiding a major lie, whether it’s a fake credit report, a manipulated employment letter, or counterfeit pay stubs.

This surge in fraud is driven by a perfect storm:

1. A Crisis of Affordability: Record-high rents and persistently low vacancy rates are pushing applicants who might not legitimately qualify to look for a way to cheat the system.

2. Digital Ease: Anyone with a basic knowledge of digital editing or access to cheap online services can create a shockingly convincing bank statement or letter of employment in minutes. The barrier to fraud has never been lower.

3. A Broken Eviction Process: With backlogs at provincial Landlord and Tenant Boards (LTBs), fraudsters know that once they get the keys, they could potentially stay for six to nine months without paying rent before a resolution is reached. This is a lucrative, low-risk gamble for them, and a devastating loss for you.

The Financial Fallout: More Than Just Missed Rent

When a fraudulent tenant slips through, the cost is immediately measurable and rapidly compounds. The initial loss is the rent, which stops the moment the tenant realizes they’ve secured the unit. But that’s just the start.

A single eviction process tied to a fraudulent tenant can easily turn an otherwise profitable unit into a five-figure financial black hole.

• Legal and Administrative Costs: Filing fees, process server costs, paralegal or lawyer fees—these expenses accumulate quickly and are rarely, if ever, recoverable.

• Property Damage: Tenants who lie their way into a unit often have little respect for the property itself. We often see extensive damage, excessive wear and tear, and sometimes even by-law infractions (like illegal rooming arrangements) that require thousands of dollars in repairs after they are finally gone.

• Lost Time and Opportunity: The time your staff spends chasing arrears, preparing for tribunal hearings, and re-listing a unit is time not spent on valuable asset management or growing your portfolio. This is a costly distraction for any professional property owner.

• Reputation and Security: Fraudulent tenants often lead to neighborhood complaints and instability within your multi-family building, which can negatively impact the quality of your other tenancies.

• 
  

Simply put, allowing a bad application to bypass your screening process is a business failure that can erode the entire annual return of an investment property.

The Professional’s Playbook: Elevating Your Due Diligence

Given the stakes, a quick phone call and a peek at a pay stub are not just inadequate—they are negligent. To protect your investment properties, your screening process needs to be forensic and operate with the assumption that every document is a lie until proven otherwise.

1. Always Use a Professional Credit Check Service

Never accept a credit report that the applicant hands you. These are the easiest documents to fake. You must use a reputable, authorized third-party screening service (like SingleKey or others) to pull a hard check directly from a credit bureau (Equifax or TransUnion). This ensures authenticity and provides a professional risk assessment based on real-time financial data.

2. Triple-Verify Employment and Income

The employment letter and pay stubs are the primary points of fraud. Your verification needs to be surgical:

• Independent Contact: Do not use the contact information listed on the employment letter. Independently search for the company’s main phone number and ask to be transferred to the HR or Payroll department. Fraudsters often provide a disconnected number or the cell phone of an accomplice.

• Cross-Check with Company Presence: Is the company legitimate? Does its online presence and size align with the applicant’s reported salary and role? A "Director" at a company with no online footprint is a massive red flag.

• Demand Bank Statements: Request the last few months of bank statements to confirm the payroll deposits actually landed in the applicant’s account. This is the single strongest piece of evidence, as a fake pay stub will have no corresponding bank history. Look for consistency in the dates and amounts.

3. Scrutinize the Rental History

The previous landlord is your best source of truth, but they, too, can be an accomplice.

• Verify Ownership: Use public records to ensure the name of the previous landlord matches the registered owner of the property address on the application.

• Ask Smart Questions: Ask open-ended questions that are difficult to prep for: "How much notice did they give you before leaving?" or "What was the final move-out condition of the property?" Look for hesitation or overly enthusiastic, rehearsed answers.

The Clear Path Forward for Your Portfolio

In today's rental market, where fraud is running rampant, your return on investment is directly correlated to the rigor of your applicant screening. This isn't just about managing risk; it's about protecting your core business value.

This is where professional property management becomes a necessity, not a luxury. At Red Maple Property Management, we recognize the existential threat posed by application fraud. We utilize industry-leading practices and technology to perform multi-layered verification and due diligence, ensuring that all applicants are fully and authentically screened before a lease is presented. Our goal is to secure the highest-quality tenants for your multi-family and mixed-use assets, safeguarding your income stream from the moment the lease is signed.

To discuss how Red Maple Property Management can bring our expert leasing services and robust tenant screening process to your Hamilton-based portfolio, please contact us today.